Pension vs lump sum calculator
A monthly pension and a one-time lump sum are the same thing priced two ways. This solves for the break-even return — the rate the invested cash has to earn, every year, to match the pension.
Break-even return
—
Enter your numbers above.
How the math works
The pension is an annuity: a fixed payment every month for as long as you live. To compare it with cash today, you discount each future payment back to the present at some rate, then add the pieces up. That sum is the present value of the pension.
Where PMT is the monthly payment (stepped up by any COLA each year), i is the monthly discount rate, n is the number of months, and m indexes each month. The break-even return is the one value of the annual rate that makes this present value equal the lump sum. Present value falls as the rate rises, so there is exactly one such rate, and the calculator finds it by bisection.
That break-even rate is the whole decision in one number. It is the return the invested lump sum must earn, year after year, to leave you exactly where the pension would. Earn more and the cash wins; earn less and the pension wins.
Here is the part most calculators skip: the lump-sum offer is not a round number someone picked. A private plan has to compute it as the present value of your pension, discounted at the three IRS segment rates under §417(e), using a mandated mortality table. The offer already embeds a discount rate. So the break-even you solve for is, roughly, the rate the plan used — and beating it means beating a bond-like rate while carrying investment risk the pension doesn't.
Worked example
Take a worker offered $2,500 a month for life with no cost-of-living adjustment, or a $400,000 lump sum. They claim at 65 and plan to a 25-year horizon, which lands at age 90 — roughly where the Social Security period life table puts a 1-in-4 chance a 65-year-old woman is still alive.
Over 25 years the pension pays $750,000 in nominal dollars. The break-even return comes out to about 5.7%. That is the headline: the lump sum has to earn 5.7% a year, every year, for 25 years, to match the monthly checks.
Now price the two options at a real return assumption. At the S&P 500's long-run nominal return of 10.2%, the pension is worth about $270,904 in present-value terms — well below the $400,000 on the table. On an average-return basis, taking the cash and investing it wins by roughly $129,000.
The catch is in the words "on average." That 10.2% carries decades of volatility and sequence-of-returns risk; the pension carries none. And because this pension has no COLA, the Federal Reserve's 2.0% long-run inflation target quietly eats the fixed payment — about a fifth of its purchasing power gone over the first decade. The break-even number is clean. The decision around it is not.
When this calculator is wrong
A single break-even rate looks decisive. Four things move it, and three of them cut against the pension's apparent safety:
- The horizon is a guess, and the guess is usually too short. The break-even rate rises the longer the pension pays, because a longer stream is worth more. Most comparison tools default to 85 or 90. The SSA period life table puts roughly 25% of 65-year-old women alive at 90 and about 10% at 95. Plan to a single "average" age and you undervalue the pension for the quarter of people who outlive it.
- A fixed pension loses to inflation; the calculator discounts that but doesn't flag it. If your pension has no COLA — most private plans don't — the real value of each check shrinks. At 2.0% inflation that is about a fifth of the purchasing power over ten years. A COLA changes the answer enough that it belongs in the inputs, not a footnote.
- The pension depends on the plan staying solvent. If a single-employer plan fails, the PBGC guarantees up to $89,181 a year at age 65 in 2025 (up from $85,295 in 2024). Below that ceiling, most pensions are covered in full and the credit risk is small. Near or above it, or in a visibly underfunded plan, the lump sum removes a risk the break-even math never shows.
- It assumes you actually invest the lump sum. The break-even return only matters if the cash goes into a portfolio earning it. A lump sum rolled straight to an IRA keeps its tax deferral; taken as cash, it is taxed as ordinary income in one year and can trigger withholding and an early-withdrawal penalty. Spent rather than invested, the comparison is moot.
What to do with the result
Read the break-even against what you would actually earn. If it sits below the yield on an investment-grade bond portfolio — the kind of return a cautious retiree would target anyway — the pension is the better-priced deal, and you keep it unless you need the liquidity or doubt the plan. If the break-even sits above a stock portfolio's expected return, the lump sum is priced generously; take it and invest it.
In the wide middle, where the break-even lands between a bond return and a stock return, the math stops deciding and your risk tolerance takes over. The practical next steps: ask the plan for the segment rates behind the offer, check where your benefit sits against the PBGC ceiling, and — if you lean toward the cash — confirm you can roll it to an IRA rather than taking it in hand.
Common questions
- Is it better to take a pension or a lump sum?
- Whichever beats the break-even return. If you can reliably earn more than the break-even rate on the invested lump sum, the cash wins; if not, the monthly pension wins. The calculator turns the choice into that one comparison instead of a gut feeling.
- What return do I need to beat my pension?
- Exactly the break-even rate this calculator solves for. It is the annual return the lump sum must earn, every year across your whole horizon, to match the pension's payments. A longer life expectancy and a COLA both push that rate higher.
- Are pension lump sums taxed?
- A lump sum paid directly to you is taxed as ordinary income in the year you receive it, and can face mandatory withholding plus an early-withdrawal penalty before age 59½. Rolled directly into an IRA or another qualified plan, it keeps its tax deferral and nothing is owed until you withdraw.
- Does my pension have a cost-of-living adjustment?
- Most private-sector pensions don't. Unlike Social Security and most government pensions, private defined-benefit plans rarely index payments to inflation, so a fixed benefit loses real value every year. If yours does have a COLA, enter it — it raises the break-even rate and the pension's value.
- What happens to my pension if the company goes bankrupt?
- For a single-employer plan, the PBGC steps in and guarantees benefits up to a cap — $89,181 a year at age 65 in 2025. Benefits below the cap are generally paid in full. The lump sum, by contrast, is yours outright and carries no plan-solvency risk once it is in your account.