Tax-equivalent yield calculator
Work out what a tax-free municipal yield is actually worth to you, once your federal, state, and NIIT rates are applied — and the marginal rate below which a taxable bond beats it.
Tax-equivalent yield
—
Enter your numbers above.
How the math works
A municipal bond pays interest that is exempt from federal income tax, and — if it was issued by your own state — from your state income tax too. To compare it fairly against a taxable bond, you gross the muni yield up to the pre-tax yield a taxable bond would need to pay to leave you the same amount after tax. That grossed-up figure is the tax-equivalent yield.
The combined marginal rate is your federal bracket, plus your state rate if you hold an in-state bond, plus the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax if your income clears its threshold. A taxable bond's interest is exposed to all three; the muni escapes them, so all three enter the gross-up.
The calculator then does the part most tools skip: it finds the break-even rate. Set the tax-equivalent yield equal to the taxable yield and solve for the tax rate, and the rate that makes them equal is:
Above that combined rate the muni wins. Below it, the taxable bond pays more after tax, no matter how the tax-free number is dressed up. A calculator that returns the tax-equivalent yield and goes no further has done half the arithmetic and called it a day.
Worked example
Take a single filer in the 24% federal bracket who also pays Illinois' flat 4.95% state tax. They're weighing an in-state AAA municipal bond yielding 3.20% against an investment-grade corporate bond yielding 5.00%.
The combined marginal rate is 24% + 4.95% = 28.95%. Grossing the muni up: 3.20% ÷ (1 − 0.2895) = 4.50%. That's the tax-equivalent yield — and it lands below the 5.00% taxable bond. At this bracket, the corporate bond wins by about 50 basis points after tax.
Now the break-even: 1 − (3.20 ÷ 5.00) = 36%. The muni only pulls ahead once the combined rate crosses 36%. With Illinois' 4.95% attached, the federal piece has to reach the 32% bracket (32% + 4.95% = 36.95%) before the muni is the better buy. A filer in a no-income-tax state needs the full 37% federal bracket to get there on federal tax alone.
That is the whole decision in one number. The tax-free headline yield is lower; whether it beats the taxable alternative is a question about your bracket, not about the bond.
When this calculator is wrong
The gross-up is exact arithmetic, but the inputs carry assumptions that decide the answer. Four of them bite hardest:
- Comparing against a Treasury double-counts the state break. Treasury interest is already exempt from state and local tax under 31 U.S.C. §3124(a). If the taxable bond you'd otherwise buy is a Treasury, drop the state rate from the gross-up — the muni's state exemption buys you nothing the Treasury doesn't already have. Use a corporate bond or a CD as the comparator when you want the state rate to count.
- The 3.8% NIIT belongs in the rate for high earners. Once modified AGI clears $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (joint), the taxable bond's interest carries the Net Investment Income Tax, so the real gross-up rate is 3.8% higher than the bracket alone. Muni interest escapes the NIIT — but it still counts toward the MAGI that pushes other income over the threshold.
- Some munis are not fully tax-free. Interest on a private-activity municipal bond is a preference item for the Alternative Minimum Tax, so for an AMT filer the "tax-free" assumption fails. And any capital gain from selling a muni before maturity is fully taxable, federal and state.
- Equal yields are not equal risk. The tax-equivalent yield compares after-tax income, not default or liquidity risk. A single-issuer muni and a Treasury at the same tax-equivalent yield are not the same bet. Match credit quality before you let the yield decide.
What to do with the result
Read the break-even rate as a threshold. If your combined marginal rate sits below it — which, against a 5.00% taxable bond at a 3.20% muni, means below 36% — the taxable bond pays more after tax, and the tax-free label is a worse deal wearing a nicer name. Buy the taxable bond, and hold it inside a tax-advantaged account if you have the room, so the interest is sheltered anyway.
If your rate is above the break-even, the muni wins. Prefer a bond issued by your own state to capture the state exemption, keep taxable bonds in your 401(k) or IRA, and leave the munis in the taxable account where their exemption does some work. Run your own current yields through the calculator — the spread between the two, not today's levels, is what moves the threshold.
Common questions
- What counts as a good tax-equivalent yield?
- There's no fixed number. A tax-equivalent yield is "good" only relative to the taxable bond you'd otherwise buy. The test is whether it clears that taxable yield at your combined marginal rate — which is why this calculator shows both the grossed-up figure and the break-even rate, not just the headline number.
- Are municipal bonds worth it in a low tax bracket?
- Usually not. Munis yield less before tax precisely because the interest is exempt, so at a low bracket the gross-up doesn't lift them past a taxable bond. In the worked example it takes a combined rate near 36% — roughly the 32% federal bracket plus a state tax — before the muni pulls ahead. Below that, a taxable bond or a Treasury pays more after tax.
- Do I pay state tax on municipal bond interest?
- Not on a bond issued by your own state, in most states — that's the "in-state" or double-exempt case, and it's when the state rate belongs in the gross-up. A bond from another state is exempt from federal tax but taxed by your state, so for an out-of-state muni you set the state rate to zero.
- Should the calculation include the 3.8% NIIT?
- If your modified AGI is over $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (joint), yes. The taxable bond's interest is subject to the surtax and the muni's is not, so leaving it out understates the muni's edge for high earners. Below the threshold, leave the box unchecked.